The Woodward News

Local News

October 8, 2012

Administrators say delay in releasing grades may be a positive sign

Woodward, Okla. — The State Department of Education's release of the A-F School Report Cards for all Oklahoma schools has been postponed.

The report cards were originally scheduled for release following a special meeting Monday of the State Board of Education, in which board members were slated to discuss approval of the report cards.  However, according to an Education Department press release, the state board tabled a vote on acceptance of the report cards until the full board meeting on Oct. 25.

"The State Board of Education has some questions about the way state average growth was calculated, and they asked for staff to consider an alternate growth calculation formula," said Tricia Pemberton, communications specialist for the Oklahoma State Department of Education.

Woodward Superintendent Tim Merchant said he believes the delay may be a positive thing.

"We're pleased, not because we're hiding anything or because we expected to be disappointed with the results,  but because it means the state board is listening to the schools' and the public's concerns with the equity, fairness, and clearness of how these scores are figured," Merchant said.

Mooreland Superintendent Terry Kellner expressed similar concerns regarding the fairness of the grades, stating "The biggest problem is getting one report card to fairly judge all the different dynamics of different school sizes."

Fort Supply Superintendent Pat Howell also said, "It would appear in some cases that it can be a distinct disadvantage to be a small school district."

However, Howell noted that he realizes that creating a fairer system may be challenging.

"I don't know if it'd be possible to come up with a system like that that isn't skewed in some way," he said.

Beyond the belief that the new A-F school grading system might be skewed against smaller schools, local superintendents also had complaints about the way the Education Department has, or has not, addressed concerns about the new system.

"What disappoints me," Merchant went on to say," is the general positioning that school officials feel they have to do in order to be heard. There has not been a great deal of communication or collaboration between the State Department of Education and schools."

Kellner expressed similar dissatisfaction, stating that when Mooreland officials called the Department of Education with questions about the A-F school grading system, "it was weeks before we got an answer back."

"The truth is when questions or concerns were raised by schools, they've been pushed to the back burner," Merchant said.

In addition, the Woodward superintendent said it was "a major concern" that the Education Department seemed intent on "releasing the grades regardless of wether they were correct or not."

Merchant explained, "For a long time we've had to validate multiple omissions in the tests. There have been differences in the state data and school data, and at one point the scores first ran had flipped data from Individual Education Program students and English Language Learners. If that data was flipped, it raises questions."

So now that the release of the school grades have been delayed, Merchant said, "I'm glad they're stepping back and saying 'We may have a problem, let's take a deeper look at the fairness, equity, and reliability of these grades.'"

However, just revising calculations used to determine a school district's grade won't be enough for Merchant, unless those calculations go beyond state testing scores.

"My argument will always be that a one day snapshot of how a student does on one test does not accurately reflect the performance of that student or that school," he said.

Text Only
Local News
  • House sends income tax cut to governor

    OKLAHOMA CITY (AP) — Legislation that would trim Oklahoma's personal income tax rate when state revenue improves was approved by the House on Wednesday in spite of objections that it's irresponsible in the face of critical education, health care and transportation needs.

    April 24, 2014

  • FOP to host debate for candidates

    Woodward's Fraternal Order of Police chapter is sponsoring a debate on May 20 between the two candidates hoping to become the next District 26 District Attorney.

    April 24, 2014

  • Movie premiere Thursday

    A film company interested in continuing a trend of production in the area will screen their latest full length film "Wichita" Thursday (April 24) at the Woodward Arts Theatre at 7 p.m.

    April 24, 2014

  • Personal security focus of weekend class for women

    Self-defense and personal security does not always include a physical altercation.
    The mind can often help you prevail in a potentially dangerous situation.

    April 23, 2014

  • Testing woes frustrating for students

    On Monday, Woodward 7th grader Taylor Harrison sat straight and tense in front of the computer, but she felt prepared.

    April 23, 2014

  • DSC_5249.JPG Fire units on scene of tank battery fire

    A tank battery fire that started at an oilfield disposal site northwest of Woodward early Wednesday morning continues to burn.

    April 23, 2014 3 Photos

  • City, county commissions meet

    Roundup of Monday's Woodward city and county commission meetings.

    April 22, 2014

  • Boomers win 2 in Alva festival

    The Boomer baseball team had its most successful day of the season  since March with a pair of wins in the Alva Festival on Saturday.

    April 22, 2014

  • Glitches prompt suspension of testing

    OKLAHOMA CITY (AP) — Oklahoma's public schools superintendent suspended online testing across the state on Monday after middle and high school students systemwide experienced disruptions during high-stakes standardized tests for the second consecutive year.

    April 22, 2014

  • Mooreland Art Show Saturday

    MOORELAND--There will be a lot of talent on display at the 28th annual Mooreland Spring Arts and Crafts Show.

    April 22, 2014

Business Marquee
AP Video

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.