The Woodward News

Local News

August 22, 2013

Jurors hear 4 witnesses on second day of trial



Also testifying Wednesday was Curt Terry, a special agent with the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation.

Terry testified about taking several blood samples from the bed of the pickup and a piece of a broken tooth, and sending them to the OSBI lab for analysis.  He said all were forensically matched back to Watkins.

Terry also testified about other evidence he collected away from the crime scene, including bloody clothes found at Spencer's friend's house where the trio had gone to clean up after returning to Woodward.  He never said whether any of these clothing items were analyzed to have the blood stains DNA tested.

However, he said he eventually collected a pair of shoes belonging to Yelloweagle after getting a search warrant several weeks after Watkins' death.  The shoes were sent in for OSBI analysis and it was determined they had come into contact with Watkins' blood.

Terry also testified about copies of several different phone records that he reviewed as part of his investigation, including Watkins' phone records showing numerous texts he sent to his girlfriend on the night of Sept. 22, 2010.

When asked about the content of those texts, Terry said, "Through my investigation I learned that they said Jon was wanting to go home, to go back to Woodward and wasn't being allowed to by Mr. Hager."

The OSBI agent also testified about records showing numerous phone calls between Carriger and the person she called to pick the group up from out in the county.  However, despite all those calls, he said none of the phone records he reviewed showed that any of the group including Yelloweagle, Hager, Spencer, Carriger and Bozarth ever called 9-1-1 following Watkins' death.

Spencer confirmed this during his testimony when Assistant District Attorney Chris Boring asked if they called emergency officials and Spencer testified, "I don't think we ever did."

The jury also heard testimony from 2 expert witnesses: Dr. Marc Harrison, who is a forensic pathologist with the Chief Medical Examiner's Office in Oklahoma City, and Doug Perkins, an OSBI blood spatter expert.

Harrison testified about the autopsy he performed on Watkins' body on Sept. 24, 2010.  He primarily explained a number of photographs he had taken during the autopsy to document injuries to Watkins' body.  This included graphic photographs showing damage to his brain, in the form of several hemorrhages, or areas where there was bleeding on his brain, and a photograph of an x-ray showing Watkins' broken jaw that was "most likely from a blow to the chin," Harrison said.

Other photographs showed the approximately dozen different lacerations to Watkins' face and numerous contusions to his face, back of his head, hands and knees.  But most of the injuries were "localized to his face and head and back of his hands," the pathologist said.

Harrison said that all the wounds on Watkins' body "tell a story" about how he died.

And from analyzing them, he said, "Jon Watkins told me that he had been beaten."

However, upon the defense's cross examination, Harrison said that some of the injuries, such as the large contusion to the back of the head, could also potentially be consistent with a car accident.  Upon Scimeca's questioning, he also agreed that forensic science cannot determine what specific blow might have led to Watkins' death, just that he died from multiple blunt force trauma.

Scimeca asked whether Watkins' .23 blood alcohol content (BAC), or almost 3 times the legal limit, could have exacerbated his injuries.  Harrison said "it can be argued that alcohol in the blood would allow an individual to bleed more freely."

"So we don't know that if he didn't have any alcohol in his system he may have lived or may have still died from this, we just can't tell?" Scimeca asked.  "Correct," Harrison said.

Perkins testified about the "large density of blood spatter" located in the rear of the bed of the pickup on both the driver's and passenger's side walls behind the wheel fender wells and on the tailgate.  Although he didn't respond personally to the crime scene, Perkins said he analyzed the blood splatter through photographs taken by investigators.

From the shape of the droplets, he said the majority of the spatter was created by striking a bloody object "very low or at the floor level" in the back of the truck.

"So it would not be from someone standing up, but more like someone's laying down," Perkins said.

In addition, he testified that the size of the droplets were consistent with a medium velocity impact, meaning "the blood droplets were acted upon by an object moving between 5 to 25 feet per second."  As examples, he said medium velocity impact spatter could be created when a bloody object was "struck by a 2x4, struck by a baseball bat or hit with a fist."

In summarizing his analysis, Perkins said, "The patterns, size, density and populations of the blood spatter and the injuries to the victim all indicate blunt force trauma injuries, which would be in the range of beatings, but I'm not sure of what weapon might have been used."

Text Only
Local News
  • State board votes again to delay education plan

    OKLAHOMA CITY (AP) — Oklahoma's State Board of Education voted on Wednesday for a second time to delay a formal plan for adopting new education standards in math and English amid opposition to the proposal from three education groups that represent public school boards and administrators across Oklahoma.

    July 24, 2014

  • Winners of Cudd Legacy award named

    Three veterans of the oil industry will receive this year's Bobby Joe Cudd Legacy Award during the Tri-State Oil and Gas Convention on Aug. 7 at the Woodward Conference Center.

    July 24, 2014

  • Benefit gun raffles underway

    Woodward Reserve police officers and other Woodward full time officers have come together to support one of their own.

    July 24, 2014

  • Tulsa man looking for military friend

    There are times in everyone's life when you think back and wonder whatever happened to those old friends from your past.

    July 23, 2014

  • Zoning change approved by commission

    Monday night Woodward city commissioners unanimously approved a zoning change that was contested by one local man who was protesting because he wants the neighborhood to continue its residential growth.

    July 23, 2014

  • Tangier Reunion set for Saturday, Sunday

    When Barbara (Allison) Merwin thinks back to the years she spent in the classrooms of Tangier High School, it takes a few moments for her to recall how school life was 60 years ago.

    July 23, 2014

  • Traveler Majors take regional opener

    ALVA - The Traveler Majors continued their strong Connie Mack playoff showing at Northwestern Oklahoma State University Tuesday.

    July 22, 2014

  • County OKs road use agreement

    Woodward County Commissioners on Monday approved a final version of a road use agreement between a energy company planning a wind turbine construction project near southeast Woodward County.

    July 22, 2014

  • Camp to show art is everywhere

    The Woodward Arts Theatre will become a recycling plant next week.

    July 22, 2014

  • Fairview Wrangler Rodeo turns 50 this year

    Western fun continues in Northwest Oklahoma as the Fairview Wrangler’s hosting their 50th annual rodeo.

    July 22, 2014